Nationalism and protectionism are two of the most tempting responses during dire economic times. European far-right political parties have enjoyed widespread electoral success amid the euro-zone debt crisis.
So it is not surprising to see populist and nationalistic demonstrations mushrooming across the world. In Egypt, Libya, Yemen, Sudan, Tunisia, Afghanistan, Pakistan and Bangladesh, protesters are rallying against the US over an American-made anti-Muslim "movie".
Despite the amateurism of the video and the fact that it was made not by any US government-sanctioned organisation (in fact one of the film's makers was later questioned by US police), protesters are targeting US embassies.
Demonstrators in Sudan were even urged to rally outside the German Embassy over the US-made video. Violence that took place during one rally resulted in the death of four US diplomatic personnel in Libya, including the ambassador.
In cities across China, angry protesters are rallying against the Japanese government's decision to "nationalise" the Diaoyutai Island by purchasing them from their Japanese owners.
The Japanese central government was forced to act after nationalist firebrand Shintaro Ishihara launched a successful fundraising campaign to purchase the islands and build a harbour for vessels using the Tokyo local government's private fund. Japan's nationalisation plan is aimed at stopping Ishihara's plan to escalate tension, but Chinese nationalists, of course, are not interested in the nuance of Japanese politics. Tens of thousands of patriotic protesters gathered outside Japanese embassies and consulates across mainland China, yelling anti-Japanese slogans and calling for the boycott of all Japanese goods and foods.
Sometimes, however, protesters are not at all concerned about facts, and the line between patriotic rallies and riots can thin, or vanish altogether. Taiwan's Central News Agency (CNA) last week reported that protesters in Beijing had included Master Kong in the list of boycotted Japanese goods, despite the fact that the instant-noodle company is based in Taiwan. CNA also reported that a Japanese-style barbecue restaurant co-owned by a mainland Chinese person and his Taiwanese partner became the target of so-called protests in which "rioters asked to eat for free there and ransacked it in an anti-Japanese protest".
Nationalism and populism are attractive during hard times because they give some people a scapegoat to blame the bad times on, such as European far-right parties blaming immigrants for the euro-zone debt woes. It also gives some the chance to vent their anger. Thanks to his high-profile Diaoyutais purchase plan, Ishihara is currently enjoying large popular support - though it failed to help his son Nobuteru Ishihara get elected as Liberal Democratic Party head this week.
The problem with nationalism is, of course, that it is dangerous and solves nothing. Rife nationalism during an economic downturn led to the rise of the Nazis in Germany. As the anniversary of the September 18 Incident, which marked the beginning of the Japanese invasion of China in WWII, falls this month, and with the death two weeks ago of Japan's ambassador to mainland China, Shinichi Nishimiya, Beijing and Tokyo are facing real dangers of a major escalation in diplomatic disputes and even fatal riots in China.
While some Diaoyutai activists in Taiwan are criticising the government's moderate approach in the sovereignty row as lacking in courage, Taipei is taking the mature route.
Its proposal of a peace initiative presents one of the rare moments of a government actually trying to resolve a territorial issue rather than exploit it. Taipei's pragmatism is perhaps based more on its limited international clout than wisdom or political courage, but that does not make irrational nationalism, or boycotting paying at locally owned Japanese-themed businesses, a better approach.
Latest stories in this category
- Beware the 'riot' in patriotism
- Nationalism and protectionism are two of the most..
- HIV vaccine: The next step forward
- Retail changes, wholesale disaster
We Recommend
- Highest rainfall in 50 years; more to come
- BMA urges patience; storms to soak city until..
- Red Bull heir pays Bt3m to victim's family
- Central region, South warned of more floods
Comments conditions
Users are solely responsible for their comments.We reserve the right to remove any comment and revoke posting rights for any reason withou prior notice.
Source: http://www.news.thethailandlinks.com/2012/09/28/beware-the-riot-in-patriotism/
0 comments:
Post a Comment